Blog · Everyday manners
Why does my dog whine in the car?
Most car whining is a dog that has booked a ticket to fun. Change what the car means and the noise goes with it.
Most dogs whine in the car because the car has only ever taken them somewhere exciting, so every drive is the countdown to the beach. The fix is to change what the car means, not to shush the dog.
Rule out the other two dogs first. A dog that drools, lip licks, goes flat and vomits is carsick, and that is a vet conversation. A dog that trembles and will not get in is frightened of the car itself, which is a different job. The dog I am talking about here jumps in happily and then whines, yips or full-on screams from the moment the engine starts. That dog is not sad. That dog is revving.
My own dog did this
I bought a bike trailer for Murphy, for adventures. And that is all it was ever used for. Bike comes out, trailer goes on, we go somewhere wonderful. Within about a week she was whining in the trailer. Then she was whining when the trailer came out. Then she was whining when the bike came out of the shed.
She was doing very simple maths. "Bike. Trailer. Somewhere amazing. Bike. Trailer. Somewhere amazing. Bike? BIKE?" Every trip paid off, so the excitement started earlier and earlier.
The cure arrived by accident. A couple of years ago my husband broke both his arms. I said, sweet, that's your homework. Every day he took Murphy round the block, came home, and did nothing. Round the block, home, nothing. The bike stopped meaning adventure, and the whining went with it.
Make most drives boring
Your car is that bike trailer. If every drive ends at the park, the beach or the dog's best friend's house, you have built a whining machine, and you built it with love.
So change the expectation. Most drives should end somewhere dull. Drive around the block and come home. Pull into a car park, sit for five minutes with the windows down, drive home. On a cool morning, grab yourself a coffee on the way. (On a warm day, skip the coffee. A dog never waits in a parked car once it heats up.) And when you do arrive somewhere good, do not open the door straight away. Car rides do not mean crazy.
Do not start by demanding stillness either. A revving brain cannot be still because you asked it to. Keep the drives short and boring and let the boredom do the teaching.
What to do while it whines
Nothing, mostly. No "it's okay, it's okay", no shushing, no hand through the gap with a treat, no eye contact in the rear view mirror. Every one of those pays the dog for the noise. That is eye contact and the three Ts, applied at sixty kilometres an hour.
Then sort out your own head, because this is where most people fall over. Pretend there is a chirpy bird in the back. "Oh, some bird." That is a very different mindset to "shut up, you're a dog", and your dog can read the difference in your shoulders. You cannot regulate your dog if you cannot regulate yourself. Earplugs or noise-cancelling headphones for passengers are allowed.
And read the rest of the dog, not just the noise. The whining is a symptom. In the first weeks it often keeps going while the body is already coming down: the dog that used to stand bolt upright at every passing thing now lifts its head, thinks "oh, what's that", and lies back down. That is progress, even if your ears disagree. Intensity drops first. Silence comes later.
The car is a CALM space
In the car the dog is in CALM, so set it up like CALM. A crate in the back, or a short tether to the headrest, short enough that the dog cannot climb onto the middle console. If your dog chews through leads, use a length of chain, not webbing. A dog roaming the back seat and scanning out of four windows is a dog on duty, and a dog on duty is not resting.
Arriving is part of the drive. Open the door. If the dog's head pushes out, close it. Open it again. No "wait, stay, wait", which to a dog desperate to get out is just one more thing to push against. The door does the teaching, and you never have to raise your voice. The dog comes out when it is settled, not when it is loudest.
Start before summer
This is the time of year the drives get longer and the destinations get better, which is exactly how the whining gets worse. Start the boring drives now. Two weeks of trips around the block before the first big day at the beach will make that day a lot quieter.
If the noise in the car is the tip of a dog that revs everywhere, the waterline is where that comes from, and a program is how I bring it down.
Want help with your own dog? Diona works in person in Melbourne and online anywhere.
Train with Diona